• Nyan-8 is still in beta.

    A Question about Tense Agreement

    Jun 11, 2025 20:00
    45 7 1 English
    In school we learn about tense agreement, but I am often confused as to whether or not we must use tense agreement in some sentences. While reading an entry a short while ago, I came across the following sentence: "She told me that she had been having a mental disorder since last November." According to the author, she hasn't recovered from the illness.  I suppose the author may have used tense agreement, but doesn't it sound like she has already recovered from the illness?  Two native English speakers corrected the entry, but neither of them corrected the sentence, so I might be wrong. I'm just curious. 

    Lv 10
    Last login:
    within 30 mins
    Japanese
    NATIVE
    English
    B2

    5436


    Entries Written

    756


    Corrections made

    490


    Corrections received

    • Sun
    • Mon
    • Tue
    • Wed
    • Thu
    • Fri
    • Sat
      N points
      9,140
      User rankings by N points (in the last 3 days)
      10 / 759 English
      Votes
      657
      Thanks
      657
      ID:
      ed658034